“Who owns the patent on this vaccine? Well, the people, I would say. There is no patent. Could you patent the sun?”—Dr. Jonas Salk (1914-1995), creator of the polio vaccine that has saved the lives of millions, and the mobility of millions more.
Take a step with me back in time. It’s 3 AM and you’re the intern covering the night shift. A 13-month-old boy just arrived at the emergency room. He’s had a slight fever the past couple of days, but it’s suddenly gotten much worse. He’s stopped eating and drinking, too. His parents can barely arouse him.
His name’s Cody. His father calls him Chief.
His lab tests show a high white blood cell count. He clearly has an infection, but where?
His parents are sitting together. The father is trembling. The mother sits next to him, her hand gripping his. They look up at you.
Cody has an infection, you say. His fever, his high white cell count, the fact that you can’t wake him up? It may be in his spinal fluid. We can’t treat him properly until we know for sure.
You want them to know you’re worried. But at this point, you try to avoid the word “meningitis.”
You take a deep breath and say, we can’t know until we do a spinal tap. We need your permission.
The mother begins to shake and cry. The father closes his eyes tightly and nods. Together they stand up and walk toward the waiting room, still clutching one another.
The nurse already has everything ready. The LP tray is out, the cleaning solution open, and the nurse is gently positioning the child on his side, folding his head toward his knees, arching his back, opening up the spaces between the bony prominences of the spine.
The nurse nods. She knows that 90% of a successful spinal tap is how the nurse positions the patient, and only 10% the skill of the doctor. You trust each other.
You clean the child’s lower back and place the tip of the needle against the skin, just between two of the spinous processes. The alignment has to be perfect. Zero degrees in the vertical axis. Zero in the horizontal. Then tilt the tip ever so slightly toward an imaginary line running from the needle tip to the baby’s belly button.
This is where the sweat starts to trickle down the middle of your back. You press the needle through the skin and feel a chill. The child doesn’t flinch, much less let out a whimper. He’s so lethargic he doesn’t respond.
You advance the needle forward, waiting for the two reassuring “pops,” the two sudden drops in resistance you feel as you penetrate the layers of connective tissue that surround the spinal fluid.
Pop. Pop. You’re in. You wait for the fluid to drip out into the tubes you’ll rush to the lab.
You say a silent prayer. Please, let it be clear. Clear like water. Clear like spinal fluid’s supposed to be.
Then your heart sinks. The fluid’s white, milky.
Pus.
You collect the fluid while you call out the orders. A rehearsed staccato you’ve rattled off more times than you can remember. IV Ampicillin every 6 hours. Gentamicin, every 8.
You go back out to the waiting area. The parents look up. You take a breath.
We’ll know more when we get the lab report, you say. But right now, it looks like meningitis.
The mother sobs. The father swallows hard and asks if there will be any brain damage.
You have to be honest. We don’t know yet, you say. But we’ll do everything we can.
How many times this scene played out in emergency rooms and pediatric wards across the country is impossible to say. I’ve forgotten most of my own experiences. Some, of course, you never forget.
But with the development of vaccines against Haemophilus Influenza B (HIB, the most common cause of childhood meningitis), the spread of this awful disease has dropped dramatically. Incredibly, I’ve talked to some recent medical graduates who’ve never had to perform a spinal tap.
But now all of that is changing.
Decades of vaccine-related reductions in childhood disease have lulled Americans into believing those diseases have simply disappeared. In addition, a virulent anti-vaccine crusade led by a drug-addled zealot with zero medical credibility has led millions more into rejecting all vaccines outright.
How did we get here? As I’ve written before, anti-vaxxers have been spreading lies about vaccines since the days of George Washington The reasons have been all over the map, and most of the time, just downright goofy.
Vaccines go against God’s will. They make you sick. They make you magnetic. They alter your DNA, or your RNA, or maybe your peptides, or maybe something else. I should make my own decisions. Do my own research. It’s my child, not the government’s.
Right, so it’s OK for you to let your child die?
Doctors can’t be trusted. They just want to make money by giving vaccines (that one’s particularly crazy—I could make more money in one day caring for an infected patient in the ICU than I could make from ten years of administering vaccines).
All of this went into hysterical overdrive with the advent of the COVID vaccine. Suddenly, refusing a vaccine wasn’t just a personal decision, now it was a patriotic act of defiance. Primed by conspiracy theorists, vaccine rates tumbled even further.
For a while, this wasn’t such an issue because of a phenomenon called herd immunity.
Herd immunity for a particular disease occurs when over 95% of a population is immune, such that a single flair-up can’t spread. Up until recently, this true for most serious childhood diseases. But as vaccination rates have fallen, herd immunity for diseases such as measles has gone out the window.
Early in the COVID pandemic a lot of nonsense was written about achieving herd immunity by just letting the disease “burn through” the population, since it would “only” kill about 5,000 people or so. Of course, even with a vaccine, it killed well over a million in the U.S. And herd immunity still wasn’t achieved.
In fact, there’s never been a disease in the history of mankind where herd immunity has been achieved WITHOUT a vaccine. Go ahead, try to find one.
Which brings us to measles.
Vaccinations once all but eliminated measles in this country. And the few who didn’t get vaccinated benefited from the herd immunity provided by those who did. But gradually, as vaccine rates declined, the disease has started spreading with a vengeance.
It’s not just some nuisance rash. It can infect brain tissue. Some kids get sick as hell. Many are hospitalized. Already this year it’s killed 11 kids here in the U.S.
And internationally? It’s 95,000 deaths per year—just to let you know what the risks of an anti-vax approach can be.
But wait, there’s more. Survivors may wind up with brain damage and/or blindness. Pregnant women are particularly vulnerable. The baby they carry may die. And if a baby is infected before the age of one? They have no immunity. And a vaccine won’t be effective before one year of age.
And if you have an immune deficiency? Your outcome can be disastrous.
Measles can spread like wildfire in an unvaccinated population. The disease is MOST contagious during the 4 days BEFORE the rash breaks out. You’ll be spreading it—perhaps to a grandchild, perhaps to a pregnant daughter—before you even know you have it. And the disease for them may be far worse.
But the recent measles surge may be just the canary in the coal mine. The MMR vaccination against measles also protects against rubella (sometimes called German Measles). Though it spreads less rapidly than measles and has milder symptoms for most people, it is far more deadly to an unborn child.
If a mother is infected in the first 3 months of pregnancy, the child will have a 90% chance of dying before birth or being born with a birth defect. Of the latter, a third will be dead by their first birthday.
Of course, the risk goes to zero if the mother has previously been vaccinated. But here’s the catch. The vaccine can’t be administered to a pregnant woman. It must be done before she becomes pregnant.
Early in my practice, we’d sometimes see a pregnant lady who wasn’t immune to rubella. She was usually older, hadn’t had the disease as a child, and hadn’t been vaccinated. But for her the risk was low because the country was in a state of rubella herd immunity, with low levels of viral transmission.
But now? All bets are off.
The absurdity of this antivax stuff goes even further. A newborn baby will take several days to develop its blood clotting ability. In that time, the child is susceptible to spontaneous bleeding into the brain. The results can be catastrophic.
But a single shot of Vitamin K can prevent this. We did this routinely right after birth. And now? In the current “don’t give my baby a shot!” hysteria, more parents are refusing it. And the incidence of brain bleeds is rising.
In any rational world, America’s Public Health System would be aggressively promoting vaccines and combating misinformation. The problem, of course, is our public health efforts are led by an anti-science, anti-vaccine conspiracy theorist who already has the blood of dozens of dead children in Samoa on his hands.
I’ve already written about the hypocrisy of the so-called MAHA movement. Junior’s tepid response to our health care crisis is a national crime.
And no, this isn’t because of immigration (why in god’s name do we have to keep bringing this up?). The rising disease rate is due solely to the reduction in vaccinations, and the loss of herd immunity.
The infectious diseases of the last century are still around. They haven’t magically gone away. Polio, hepatitis, and diphtheria (a disease that can cause a child to suffocate from their throat closing off) are all out there. When enough parents decide to forgo vaccinations because it’s “their choice” and herd immunity is lost, they’ll all be waiting to strike.
So get your children vaccinated. Your grandchildren, too. And remember, someone’s “choice” not to get vaccinated may mean nothing to them. But it may be the difference between life and death for that child under the age of one, that pregnant mother, or that immune compromised baby who gets exposed.
Because if Americans can’t let go of their own selfish interests when it comes to public health and our responsibility to others, then just who the hell are we anyway?
Terrific piece of work, Don. If one person gets one vaccination, you did a great public service.
Thank you, Steve. I hope so.
Don, this is a wonderful post. The first half is dramatic, gripping, and so very real. I am glad that students haven’t had to do a spinal tap in a baby, hope they never have to, and am aghast that the anti-vaxxers will probably give them chances to.
The essay is written with passion and is 100% correct. Not getting vaccinated is a threat to you, your children, my children, and everyone’s grandchildren. From your pen to God’s ears!
Thank you, Josh. I know you’ve been there, too. Many times.